Carly, a local college student, becomes involved with Abram, a young Amish man, during his Rumspringa. But Abram refuses to return home and takes Carly captive so they can be together at his own twisted version of an Amish community.

Budding New York fashion designer, Nicole, relocates to a small lake-side town for the summer to work on her first collection and spend time with her cousin, Amanda. Once in town, Nicole also meets the charismatic pastor from Amanda's church, Caleb, and his friendly wife, Jenn. However, when Amanda turns up dead in mysterious accident, Nicole begins to suspect that something is off with the handsome pastor and wonders if he could be connected to her cousin's death.

Lorelai loves living in her neighborhood, right next to best friends Jackie and Ella. During girl's night at Jackie's house a home invasion goes terribly wrong when the three women accidentally kill a man.